The Redeemed Man

When You Can't Fix It: Choosing Hope Anyway

• Paul Amos

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 53:02

What do you do when the problem in front of you is one you can't fix?

In 2008, Jay Wolf was finishing law school, raising a six-month-old son with his wife, Katherine, and imagining the life they were about to build together. Then, without warning, Katherine suffered a catastrophic brainstem stroke. Doctors didn't expect her to survive. She did, but the life Jay and Katherine had planned was gone.

In this conversation with Redeemed director Nate Dewberry, Jay shares what nearly two decades of walking through suffering, disability, marriage, fatherhood, and ministry have taught him about the kind of hope that survives when circumstances don't change the way we want them to.

Jay talks candidly about a struggle many men know well: we want to fix things. But what happens when we can't? What happens when strength looks less like solving the problem and more like allowing other people to carry us? And how do we keep disappointment from hardening our hearts?

Jay and Nate explore the power of Christian community, the unexpected treasures hidden in dark seasons, and why the hardest chapters of our lives don't have to be wasted.

Hope isn't pretending everything will turn out the way we planned. As Jay puts it, hope is “believing in advance what only makes sense in reverse.”

Segments/chapters

0:00 Intro/Jay’s wife’s traumatic health event

5:56 “A miraculous rebirth”

12:07 Where Jay and his family stood at the time of his wife’s stroke

16:11 How Jay was changed by the experience

21:03 Interlude 1/Small group promo

21:27 The “treasures” Jay and his wife discovered in their time of challenge

29:02 Men’s reluctance to accept help in times of struggle

36:30 How Jay and his wife are using their story to help others

44:50 Reflections on the “miracle” of parenthood

48:11 Interlude 2/Online group promo

48:35 What Jay has learned about hope



Visit The Redeemed's website for downloadable discussion question sets,  show notes, inspirational articles, more resources, or to share your testimony.
Join our Exclusive Newsletter: Signup today and be the first to get notified on upcoming podcasts and new resources!

The Redeemed is an organization giving men from all backgrounds a supportive, judgment-free environment, grounded in Christian love without demanding participation in any faith tradition, where they can open up about their challenges, worries, and failures—and celebrate their triumphs over those struggles.

Follow The Redeemed on Social Media: 

People on this episode